Author Topic: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer  (Read 1784 times)

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #45 on: June 17, 2009, 11:42:40 PM »
Here are the last three from 2007 in Winnipeg
2007
Aug. 30 -- Decomposed body of Fonessa Lynne Bruyere, 17, found in a field near Ritchie Street and Mollard Road.

July 15 -- Aynsley Aurora Kinch, 35, discovered in a field near Murray Road and McPhillips Street -- not far from Bruyere's.

April 19 -- Body of Crystal Shannon Saunders, 24, found in a ditch near St. Ambrose just weeks after her release on prostitution charges.

Des could you please add this young lady to your data base. Whether she was a STW is unknown but her Mo matches the same as a few other women including the way she was found and what she was wearing, or lack of what she was wearing where on her body. Thanks.
Wednesday, July 17, 1991-Glenda Morrisseau age 19, last seen at 2:30 a.m. on Logan Avenue hitching-hiking a ride downtown from the Stock Exchange Hotel. Found Wednesday, August 7, 1991, in a St. Boniface industrial area. she may have died as a result of massive trauma to the head inflicted by a large blunt object.   
« Last Edit: June 18, 2009, 12:10:31 AM by Sleuth »

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #46 on: June 18, 2009, 12:57:20 AM »
Being open minded has its benefits, especially where psychics are concerned. I found this interesting article. I recall reading somewhere on one of the threads that someone mentioned she/he thinks it may be a group responsible for some of the STW murders; Quote[Hatfield said he believes four people are involved in the murders of the women, with one person acting as the "dumping guy."]

Cop hears murdered prostitute speak
By ELIZA BARLOW -- Edmonton Sun July 5, 2006
            
A veteran city cop is convinced the voice of murdered prostitute Rachel Quinney was picked up on an audio recording as she spoke from beyond the grave.

"I saw it. I heard it. I believe," said Const. Wayne Fermaniuk, who on June 26 accompanied a psychic to the spot where Quinney's body was discovered.

"If (the psychic) was a phoney, I wanted to expose him. But he's got me. I'm convinced."

Fermaniuk, a 25-year veteran of the Edmonton Police Service, was among a small group of people who ventured to the spot in Strathcona County where the body of 19-year-old Quinney was found June 11, 2004.

Also there were Rachel's mother, Delia Quinney, and one of Rachel's sisters.

They were led by psychic and spiritual medium Alan Hatfield, from Pictou Landing First Nation in Nova Scotia.

Hatfield, who says he came to Alberta at the request of the Quinney family, set up an infrared camera and audio recorder at the site where Quinney's body was found.

Along with the voices of Fermaniuk and Quinney's mother and sister, who were all present, Rachel's voice could be heard on the tape's playback, said Hatfield.

"It was clear and came in between other dialogue," he said.

"Rachel came on, and her grandmom and granddad, who are Delia's mom and dad, they came on, too." Hatfield says he also captured images of "spiritual energies" flitting around the site.

Neither Hatfield nor Fermaniuk would reveal what they heard Rachel say on the recorded audio of the approximately hour-long session, saying it could jeopardize the police investigation into her unsolved death.

But Hatfield did say that Rachel talked about her murder. "She's very angry, very angry. She's a fighter. She didn't go down easy. She fought all the way."

Fermaniuk said the voice sounded "like a woman talking."

"I heard the clips that the mother (Delia) said were her daughter talking. It kind of sounds like it's in the background, and you have to turn it up a bit, but it's there."

Last week's visit, which Hatfield says he paid for himself, marked the second time he has visited the spot with his psychic equipment. During a half-hour session last summer, he claims a "male spirit" was captured on tape saying the word "Tom."

In May of this year, 38-year-old Thomas Svekla was charged in the murder of another sex-trade worker, Theresa Merrie Innes, whose body was found in a Fort Saskatchewan home.

The arrest was the first made by Project KARE, a task force investigating the murders and disappearances of dozens of area prostitutes in the last 30 years, including Quinney.

Hatfield said he believes four people are involved in the murders of the women, with one person acting as the "dumping guy."

Alberta RCMP spokesman Cpl. Wayne Oakes said Project KARE investigators are reviewing Hatfield's material.

"Traditional investigative technique would not say let's go out and get a psychic medium to have a seance and see what we can find out about this crime," said Oakes.

"But there have been a number of examples over the years where (information from psychics) has been fruitful."
« Last Edit: June 18, 2009, 01:02:02 AM by Sleuth »

Desespere

  • Site Member
  • Member
  • Posts: 4309
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #47 on: June 18, 2009, 10:20:10 AM »
Glenda is in my database and is on this site as well. Here's the link to her record on Unsolved.
http://www.unsolvedcanada.ca/index.php/topic,125.0.html

Yes, Alan Hatfield visited Rachel's recovery site twice. The second time he had the police officer with him.
His psychic reading fits with Svekla's arrest, what he says about him just being told about a "package" (meaning Theresa's remains in the duffel bag) that he had to deliver but he didn't kill Theresa.

Also, three or four makes sense to me, absolutely, in terms of who I suspect in Edmonton for some of or all of these 11 women's murder or disappearance, well I should say the 10 before Gail Cardinal because I know nothing of these men in 1989, but do know a lot about them between 2002-2005.

I have reported them but haven't heard anything since Feb 2005.

I'm interested that the police affadavit from Svekla's trial says there were two men that knew about the murders, had information about the murders, basically failed the lie detector test. I think these two men knew each other. I'm speculating the two men are the men I know of. But, then many of us might have people we think are capable of these crimes, or were behaving strangely around the time of these crimes.

Thank you so much Sleuth for engaging in this discussion and putting so much thought and time into answering and postulating. I wanted to bring some attention back to Edmonton cases, because that is where the concept for unsolvedcanada began, with a forum dedicated to these killings on Kare's original website. That forum was shut down, then a second forum was created, off Kare site and that forum was shut down, so Chris started this one, with his own money and time, and it has lasted over two years and is growing and getting attention from family and people that may know something. As well as all the caring people that have been posting since then.

I'm hoping more people from Edmonton or the areas where the women were recovered will remember something and say something to police. I feel they have a few clues about who is responsible and maybe just one more piece of information will allow them to put an end to the horror in Edmonton. I pray for this too - while my prayers are still with finding Victoria Stafford, God knows I pray for all the people on this site and I hope for more prayers and more answers.

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #48 on: June 19, 2009, 11:47:16 AM »
Desespere; could you email me please. I will keep my email address up for a couple of days.

Desespere

  • Site Member
  • Member
  • Posts: 4309
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #49 on: June 19, 2009, 01:12:15 PM »
'Kay, I emailed you.

Desespere

  • Site Member
  • Member
  • Posts: 4309
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #50 on: June 21, 2009, 10:40:01 AM »
This is an article published by Edmonton Journal just after the news came out in Svekla's trial that five deaths were linked together. There are details about each woman.
http://www2.canada.com/edmontonjournal/news/story.html?id=16ffbc4a-56bc-4c84-abbf-04f26baa6b4e
Published Feb 18, 2008

Five similar deaths lead police to suspect single killer
Ryan Cormier and Trish Audette, The Edmonton Journal
Published: Monday, February 18 2008

EDMONTON - By mid-2003, 10 Edmonton sex-trade workers had been killed in 14 years.

To the public, the similarities were obvious.

All worked the streets of Edmonton, usually along 118th Avenue. All were found in rural areas to the south or east of the city. All were poor, vulnerable and struggling with drug addictions. Sources have said none were shot or stabbed. There were no obvious injuries.

Each case was investigated separately, by officers in different detachments and units.

But a report from the RCMP Behavioral Sciences Branch in Ottawa changed that.

The special unit looked at the 10 murders and drew out five. According to court documents, the RCMP believe Edna Bernard, Debbie Lake, Monique Pitre, Melissa Munch and Katie Ballantyne were all victims of the same killer.

"The committee also reported at this time that this offender would continue to frequent prostitutes and murder some of them," states an RCMP affidavit.

The RCMP will not talk about how they linked the deaths, or even the process they used to arrive at such conclusions.

In October 2003, shortly after the links were confirmed, the Project Kare task force was formed, charged with investigating the deaths and disappearances of victims with high-risk lifestyles.

None of the five linked cases have been solved.

EDNA BERNARD

Four hours before her burnt body was found smouldering in a wooded area outside Leduc, Edna Bernard was dropped off near 118th Avenue and 95th Street.

The 28-year-old mother of six, a crack addict, had spent about an hour with a regular john. He told police he left her on the Avenue of Champions around 4 a.m. on Sept. 23, 2002.

Most pictures of Bernard have vanished, says her aunt, Annette Bernard. Some were lost to fire, others as family left Whitefish-Goodfish Lake First Nation for the city.

Annette Bernard's only picture of her niece -- a singed newspaper clipping -- sits in a china cabinet in her home.

"I can remember her in my mind's eye, in my heart," she says. "She was just a good little girl, a good kid. A smile that would light up the dark."

Edna Bernard looked like her maternal grandmother, with brown eyes and curly brown hair. Five-foot-four and slight of build, she was raised by her mother, aunts and grandmother on the 2,000-person reserve located 150 kilometres northeast of Edmonton.

As a adult, Bernard did not speak to her family of life on Edmonton's streets.

"She had so many bad breaks in life. ... She was so soft-hearted," Annette Bernard remembers. "That word, prostitute, I hate it."

Annette Bernard had stopped singing before Edna's death, but after she died, Annette could hear Edna command: "Aunty, sing for me."

Edna's favourite song was a First World War-era hymn -- "Life's evening sun is sinking low / a few more days and I must go / to meet the deeds that I have done / where there will be no setting sun."

"I think of her, this bouncing little girl, hippity-hopping down the road," Annette Bernard says.

DEBBIE LAKE

Debbie Darlene Lake was only going out to a pay phone to call a friend when she left her home in the early morning of Nov. 4, 2002. She had left behind both both her 10-month-old child and her cigarettes.

Her husband reported her missing the next day; for six months, there was no word. On April 12, 2003, a man looking for deer antlers near Miquelon Lake north of Camrose found a skull. In August, a DNA test confirmed it was Lake's.

The rest of her body was never found.

Lake moved from Bancroft, Ont., to Edmonton as an exuberant 13-year-old. Problems began in high school, and she dropped out when she turned 18.

"She had moved away from home and was living with her boyfriend at her aunt's place," says her mother, Mary Lake. "She'd sooner go out and party with them and not bother going to school."

By then the rest of the Lake family lived in Barrhead; Debbie was in Edmonton.

When she was 19, Lake got one of the biggest scares of her life. Doctors said she had cervical cancer, which could make it impossible for her to have children.

"It really upset her because she always loved kids," Mary Lake says.

Cancer treatments were successful. She married at 20 and gave birth to her first child one year later. That little girl was the first of four children.

Lake had separated from her husband, then reconciled. They lived in a bus in Edmonton. She was making her first serious attempt to stabilize her life, and wanted to reunite with all her children.

Lake reportedly worked the sex-trade in Edmonton, though her mother doesn't believe it. "Debbie liked to dress up nice, she wanted nice clothes and nice things. To stoop that low, she would not do it."

MELISSA MUNCH

A picture of Melissa Munch at about age 20 shows the pretty blond in the back of a police car. Her arms are clasped behind her back. Her mouth and eyes are tough.

Addicted to crack cocaine, she was known to steal from the johns she turned tricks for along 118th Avenue or in Little Italy near Giovanni Caboto Park.

She had two daughters, one just 11 months, the other five years old.

On Jan. 12, 2003, her frozen body was found near Ardrossan.

Munch was last seen between Jan. 6 and Jan. 10 at a pharmacy on 118th Avenue near 95th Street.

She grew up in the Calgary neighbourhood of Bowness, an area where brand new houses are regularly being built to replace run-down ones.

At Bowness Hotel bar, regulars remember Doris Munch. She worked there, and patrons remember her two cute little girls, Melissa and Jessica.

The girls went to Our Lady of Assumption school, where a white cross hangs starkly against dark bricks. Staff will not talk about them.

"It was pretty tragic," says Deacon Paul Coderre, who presided over Munch's funeral in 2003.

MONIQUE PITRE

On Nov. 24, 2002, Monique Pitre got a ride from a roommate to the Transit Hotel in northeast Edmonton. That was the last confirmed sighting of the 30-year-old.

She was known as a sex-trade worker who had been around a while and knew how to be smart on the streets.

Later, some people would recall seeing Pitre in December 2002. A security guard at the Cecil Hotel thought he saw her just after New Year's Day.

But nothing was certain until her body was found on Jan. 9, 2003, in a field northeast of the city. Investigators believe she had been there for several days.

She had not been reported missing.

"I was shocked because Monique had been around for awhile, and knew better," a fellow sex-trade worker said then.

Pitre was born in Bathurst, N.B., then moved to Petawawa, Ont., with her mother and two older brothers when she was five. A "girly-girl," Pitre dressed up her dolls and spent hours in front of a mirror trying to apply makeup to her young face, says mother Rose Imhoff.

According to family, her problems began in Grade 10, when she started a drug habit among a different crowd.

She ran away from home soon after.

Pitre came to Edmonton on the invitation of a friend. Pitre then stopped calling home, and her family couldn't keep track of her.

KATIE SYLVIA BALLANTYNE

She would be right back.

That is what Katie Sylvia Ballantyne told her friend Jack Perrault when she left his McCauley-area home late on April 27, 2003: She would work the streets and be back soon.

On July 7, 2003, her skeletal remains were found in a field east of Leduc.

"She had a sickness and she wasn't well. Some guy decided she was nothing and he murdered her," says Victoria Merasty, Ballantyne's mother. "She was a human being."

Merasty visits her daughter's grave in Saskatoon every Mother's Day, but has no interest in Edmonton, the city that took Ballantyne's life.

Ballantyne was addicted to crack cocaine, and worked near 111th Avenue and 95th Street.

Merasty believes her daughter's addictions started with the Ritalin she took after her divorce. She sold sex to pay her dealers.

"Saskatoon, the street where the girls walk, was very visible. I think she was ashamed that I would see her or her kids would see her," she says. "She didn't want us to know about it, but we knew."

The eldest of eight children, Ballantyne was born in Le Pas, Man. Her father was Greek, her mother Opaskwayak Cree.

Bernard, Lake, Munch, Pitre and Ballantyne are just five victims among almost 20 who have disappeared.

Their families hear little from RCMP. They don't know if there have been any clues in the cases, or any new information.

There is still hope, though, says former vice officer JoAnn McCartney.

McCartney works with the Prostitution Action and Awareness Foundation of Edmonton, counselling women who work in the sex trade. She knew all five women.

"Certainly people who work in the network of support agencies, we know it couldn't all just be one" killer, McCartney says.

"They're easy pickings. ... They're vulnerable, they're addicts. If someone hurts them they're not going to be good witnesses," she says.

"There are lots of people in society who think these women are disposable."

taudette@thejournal.canwest.com

rcormier@thejournal.canwest.com

- - -

Q&A

Q: What is Project Kare?

A: An RCMP-led task force investigating the disappearances and deaths of Alberta women and men who led high-risk lifestyles.

Q: How many cases is Project Kare investigating?

A: The number fluctuates, but the task force has been investigating more than 70 cases of missing or dead Albertans, including 13 sex-trade workers found dead outside Edmonton since 1989.

Q: What is a high-risk lifestyle?

A: The victims are usually involved in the sex trade, have drug addictions, or are homeless.

Q: How many people make up Project Kare?

A: The task force is made up of roughly 50 people, including 35 Mounties and four Edmonton Police Service officers.

Q: How many tips has Project Kare received?

A: Thousands. A single file can fill 80 boxes.

Q: How many arrests has Project Kare made?

A: One. Thomas George Svekla, 38, was arrested in May 2006. He was charged with second-degree murder and interfering with a dead body in connection with the death of 36-year-old Theresa Merrie Innes. Svekla is also charged with second-degree murder and offering an indignity to a body in the death of Rachel Quinney, a 19-year-old sex-trade worker found in a field east of the city on June 11, 2004.

Q: Why is Kare spelled with a K?

A: The Alberta division of the RCMP is known as K-Division. The names of all projects and task forces must begin with a K.

© The Edmonton Journal 2008

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #51 on: June 23, 2009, 01:52:18 PM »
I have not been able to find what I stumbled upon. Sigh. But maybe I will stumble upon it again.

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #52 on: July 05, 2009, 01:59:35 AM »
I noticed in your last post Des that the women's names have only four or five alpha letters, either their first name or their last name. I'm wondering also if any of the places the women were found have any matching first letters, Like a C for instance? Or the spot where they were taken from have any first matching letters? Any Lakes nearby, or rivers, or streams with the first matching letters? I don't know the area at all as well as you do so I thought I would ask.

Desespere

  • Site Member
  • Member
  • Posts: 4309
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #53 on: July 05, 2009, 01:24:29 PM »
Edna Bernard
Last seen in Edmonton September 23, 2002. Recovered from a field in Leduc County. There is no obvious large bodies of water in the area Edna was recovered. Although the field I suspect she was found has a tree line that looks like Italy when looking at a satellite image.

Debbie Lake
Last seen in Edmonton and recovered South of Miquelon Lake in Camrose County.

Melissa Munch
Last seen at 95st and 118 ave at a drug store, Shoppers Drug Mart and found in Strathcona County.
I cant find anything that matches

I will have to continue this later.
 



Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #54 on: July 05, 2009, 11:50:30 PM »
Des; Does the field Edna was found in have a name, or a nickname? Was she found out in the open? Or close to the tree line? Was it a farmers field? If it was do you know the farmers name? Or the last names of near neighbours? How far from the road was she?
Do you know how far south of the lake that Debbie was found? Was she out in the open or hidden? How far from the road was she?
Do you know where in Strathcona County Melissa was found? Out in the open or hidden? How far from the road was she?
And the other women? out in the open or hidden and do you know how far from the or a road?

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #55 on: July 09, 2009, 05:28:25 PM »
I'm wandering if there are any Street Hawks where the STW hang.

Desespere

  • Site Member
  • Member
  • Posts: 4309
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #56 on: July 09, 2009, 11:49:59 PM »
Hi Sleuth, sorry for the long delay in answering.

I do not know the answers to any of the questions you've asked. I don't have specific details about locations. I make a guess, more or less, closest reasonable spot to the crossroads given in news reports or police press releases.

Sleuth

  • Member
  • Posts: 1060
    • View Profile
Re: Police believe up to 11 prostitutes may be victims of same killer
« Reply #57 on: August 10, 2009, 01:45:50 PM »
I'm putting this article here since Des and I had a discussion about Psychopaths on this thread. I remember a time, long, long ago, when disturbed people were given lobotomies. I'm wondering if lobotomies would work on psychopaths?

Psychopaths have faulty brain connections: study
By Kate Kelland

LONDON (Reuters) - Psychopaths who kill and rape have faulty connections between the part of the brain dealing with emotions and that which handles impulses and decision-making, scientists have found.

In a study of psychopaths who had committed murder, manslaughter, multiple rape, strangulation and false imprisonment, the British scientists found that roads linking the two crucial brain areas had "potholes," while those of non-psychopaths were in good shape.

The study opens up the possibility of developing treatments for dangerous psychopaths in the future, said Dr Michael Craig of the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College London, and may have profound implications for doctors, researchers and the criminal justice system.

"These were particular serious offenders with psychopathy and without any other mental illnesses," he told Reuters in an interview.

"Essentially what we found is that the connections in the psychopaths were not as good as the connections in the non-psychopaths. I would describe them as roads between the two areas -- and we found that in the psychopaths, the roads had potholes and weren't very well maintained."

TIMING IS KEY

The scientists cautioned against suggestions the study could lead to screening of potential psychopathic criminals before they are able to commit crimes, saying their findings had not established how, when or why the brain links were damaged.

"The most exciting question now...is when do the potholes come -- are people born with them, do they develop early in life, or are they a consequence of something else?"

Psychopathic extremes have been portrayed in Hollywood blockbusters by characters like the serial killer and cannibal Hannibal Lecter. Psychopaths often violate social norms, are manipulative, impulsive and sensation-seeking, and appear to feel no empathy or remorse.

Craig, who conducted the study, published in the journal Molecular Psychiatry with colleagues Declan Murphy and Dr Marco Catani, stressed that the numbers in the brain scan study were small, with only nine psychopaths analyzed and compared with nine non-psychopaths.

"Trying to get people of this particular type to take part in a study, and also then deal with all the security you need to get them into a brain scanner, is not an easy feat," he said.

The study used new brain imaging technology to further analyze psychopaths' brains after previous studies found that the amygdala part of the brain, which processes emotions, and orbitofrontal cortex, which handles impulses and decisions, are structurally and functionally different in psychopaths.

"Up until recently the technology hasn't been available to look at the connections between those two brain areas in any meaningful way," Craig said.

But a new technique, called diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging (DT-MRI), allowed the researchers to look at the white matter tract linking the two key brain areas.

As well as finding clear structural deficits in the tract in psychopathic brains, they also found the degree of abnormality was significantly linked to the degree of psychopathy.

"As for the moral significance for society, and how society wants to deal with these things, that is a little premature," said Craig. "This is a small study and the important thing it raises is that more research needs to be done."

 

Anywhere.ca

SHARIN'

A documentary casefile about the murder of nine year old Sharin' Morningstar Keenan on January 23, 1983, Toronto. Radio, Television, and Online versions of this story are all unique in their own way and together form the whole program. click here